What’s Your Source?

Several conversations I’ve had have ended with agreeing to disagree because we rely on differing sources of information.

One such conversation involved a government conspiracy. Here’s a summary of my conversation with Ralph (not his real name) which took place at a fast food restaurant in Rome NY:

Ralph: So is that your cart out front?

Me: That’s right. I’m walking across the country to raise awareness about climate change.

Ralph: Have you heard about chem trails?

Me: You mean the contrails left behind jet engines.

Ralph: No. I mean chemical trails deliberately sprayed into the upper atmosphere to cause global warming.

Me: Why would the government want to cause global warming?

Ralph: So that they can justify a socialist agenda to fight global warming.

Me: But what about all of the climate scientists who have made the case that climate change is being caused by the burning of fossil fuels like gasoline, jet fuel and coal?

Ralph: Most of those scientists are being paid by the government. They’re in on the conspiracy.

Another conversation took place on the Erie Canal Trail. Tom (not his real name) and a friend were riding by when they stopped to ask about my walk.

Tom: So what’s the story?

Me: I’m walking across the country to raise awareness about climate change.

Tom: I hear ya? I know global warming is happening, but do you really think it’s anthropromorphic?

Me: The scientific consensus is that global warming is caused by human activities.

Tom: No. There’s no scientific consensus that makes that connection. There are plenty of scientists who disagree.

Me: But a recent study of the climate change literature, found that about 97% of climate science papers agree with the notion of human induced climate change. (see http://theconsensusproject.com)

Tom: I am a scientist with a degree from MIT and I can tell you that carbon dioxide is not harmful – in fact, CO2 is necessary for plant growth. The problem is not CO2, it’s the sun and the expansion of the earth. Look it up.

Finally, I had a brief conversation in Macedon NY with a young woman who was curious about the cart.

Maggie (not her real name): What’s the cart for?

Me: I’m walking across the country and I’m using the cart to carry my things – sleeping bag, duffel, tent ect.

After giving me some suggestions to improve the cart, Maggie asked: “What’s the purpose of the walk?”

Me: I’m trying to raise awareness about climate change. I think, as a country, we aren’t making any progress towards addressing it.

Maggie: Well I know the weather has been strange but there’s nothing we can do about it. It’s just God’s plan. Its part of the end times. It was foretold that the weather would become erratic in the end times.

All of these conversations end the same way. We agree to disagree because we trust different information sources. So how can we proceed if we can’t agree that there is a scientific consensus? I’m afraid we have to start there because all discussion stops if we can’t agree on that consensus.

2 thoughts on “What’s Your Source?

  1. Brent Jaimes

    I just learned about your walk and it’s really cool to hear about. “What’s your source” just confirms that science isn’t a democracy. There are some, even a lot of things, that we can be reasonably scientifically certain about. One of these is the idea that human activity is causing and will continue to cause global temperatures to rise. And we can know with reasonable scientific certainty what actions we can take to change this trend. We don’t get to vote on the science or choose to reject it because it doesn’t fit our political, economic, or sociological belief system. Or at least we do so at our peril.
    You’re walk is hopefully making more folks aware of these things.

  2. victoria

    I was glad to speak with you about your walk. I stopped in to Old Station 1 FD restaurant in harborcreek, pa and had a short chat. Good luck!
    Stay safe!
    Victoria Knight


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

five − = 3

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>